Regarded as an experienced leadership adviser within the insurance sector, Mary MacDonald is dedicated to helping clients drive growth by attracting and developing transformative executive talent with the capabilities and cultural understanding to lead in a highly demanding and dynamic landscape. Mary is a member of Spencer Stuart’s Insurance, Financial Services, Board and CEO, and Human Resources practices — with a portfolio of clients that includes public and mutual Fortune 500 companies, as well as private equity and venture-backed companies. She works closely with clients across all segments of the insurance industry, including property and casualty, life and annuities, employee benefits, health and reinsurance across all functions. Quality execution is critical to Mary’s success and intrinsic to her DNA.

Finding transformative executive talent in the insurance industry

  • Throughout her 20 years in executive search and consulting, Mary has led board of directors, C-suite and senior-level assignments across all functions, including general management, finance, operations, insurtech, risk management, actuarial, underwriting, marketing, distribution and claims positions.
  • Prior to joining Spencer Stuart, Mary spent 15 years in a global executive search firm’s insurance and HR officer practices. She also was a member of financial services, board and CEO, and diversity advisory practices.
  • Earlier in her career, Mary led the actuarial recruiting division of a boutique insurance-specific recruiting firm based in Chicago.

Mary earned a B.A. in English and pre-professional studies from the University of Notre Dame.

Practice Areas